On April 17, 2020, the Justice Centre sent letters to Prime Minister Trudeau, and to each of the ten Premiers publicly asking questions about the cost – in human life and human health – of government measures which violate the fundamental Charter freedoms of Canadians to move, travel, associate, assemble, and practice one’s faith. Replies, if any, are listed.
“The Justice Centre fully supports governments taking appropriate measures to combat the spread of COVID-19,” stated lawyer John Carpay, president of the Justice Centre.
“The Justice Centre also insists that governments meet their obligation under the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms to violate our rights as little as possible, and only to the extent that is truly necessary to achieve legitimate government objectives,” continued Carpay.
Once citizens are able to show that their rights have been violated, the onus then shifts to the government to justify its violation of those rights. This burden is on the government, not the citizens. This burden is intended by the Charter to be an onerous one.
Canada’s federal and provincial governments claim saving lives as the justification for government measures that severely violate Charter rights and freedoms. This is a worthy goal that potentially justifies violating the fundamental freedoms of citizens, at least for a limited and specified period of time. At the same time, while recognizing the legitimacy of a government’s objective, courts will also conduct a balancing exercise, requiring governments to fully weigh and consider both the harms and the benefits of government actions that violate Charter freedoms.
Under the Charter, Canada’s elected leaders are required to give very serious consideration to the number of lives that will be lost as a result of the social isolation and economic devastation that Charter-violating government measures against COVID-19 are inflicting on Canadians.