After Cowichan Tribes v. Canada, Aboriginal title under section 35 and the title held by a BC homeowner occupy the same mapped lots in southeast Richmond. The Court held that historic Crown grants there unjustifiably infringed Aboriginal title, which it treated as the prior and senior interest. It did not write a sharing rule. Federal recognition agreements now also use the language of Aboriginal title over a territory, though without mapping which lots, if any, are specifically covered. Owners remain on their lots, but lenders and appraisers do not treat the title as certain. The Cowichan appeal must settle what the Constitution requires. A coexistence statute should say what owners may rely on now, and clarify that if two titles must be reconciled, the Crown – not the landowner – pays.